IUP PROFESSOR ALISON DOWNIE FREE

It sounds so “gentle”, this killing….I certainly hope I never become one of these “Lebensunwertes Leben”….oh! You don’t remember the “Lebensunwertes Leben”? You don’t remember the past? Well, you are on the road to repeat it. It has ALL happened before! This Eugenics philosophy thing. Your gender is a scientific fact which doesn’t change no matter how you identify or how many people agree with you. They do not say, this person was born male but became female or vice versa.

When scientists look at ancient human remains, they can take one look at the pelvic bones of a skeleton and determine if the person was male or female.

IUP PROFESSOR ALISON DOWNIE FREE

While the free speech issue is certainly an important one, I am more concerned about the fact that this professor is demanding students deny reality or face punishment. “The classroom in particular must remain a place where ideas are free to be challenged and debated, no matter how deeply held,” Ari Cohn, director of FIRE’s Individual Rights Defense Program, told The College Fix in an email. His professor reported him to the provost’s office after Ingle shared his views in a class discussion on gender-related issues that reserved comments for females first. The Foundation for Individual Rights in Education takes a skeptical view of Indiana University of Pennsylvania’s stated rationale for punishing Lake Ingle, who has become a cause celebre for suppression of conservative beliefs this month. FIRE, the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education, has gotten involved.įree-speech group warns university it can’t punish student for saying there are two gendersĪ male student barred from class for “significantly disrupt the learning process” may have simply been expressing a viewpoint, making his punishment “highly inappropriate,” according to a free-speech group. The professor may end up regretting her actions in this case. Ingle described the incident on the Tucker Carlson show last night: “You are barred from attending this class in accordance with the Classroom Disruption policy,” IUP Provost Timothy Moerland told Ingle in a March 2 letter. Ingle needs to complete the class to graduate at the end of the semester. She referred him to the public university’s Academic Integrity Board (AIB). The feminist professor booted him from class and asked him not to come back. This is one of three essays published together in a special topic section of this journal on critical incidents in the classroom.He told the class that the official view of biologists is that there are only two genders. This awful class and the subsequent related events, including administrative response to the social media outrage, have led me to a deeper understanding of what it means to embrace responsibility while at the same time recognizing and accepting that I am not in control. The student responded to my request for a disciplinary hearing by launching a social media campaign to discredit me and my reasons for requesting this hearing. After this student refused to apologize in aggressively disrespectful language to me in a private meeting, I petitioned for university sanction. When one angry student refused to follow my discussion structure in a class on diverse Christian views of gender and sexuality, I was unable to keep other students in the room safe from his harmful tirade. This peer-reviewed journal has recently migrated to an open access online platform, where Downie's article' Who Speaks When?' is available. Subjecting such moments to careful critical analysis can reveal important facets of the purposes and practices of teaching.' According to the journal's editor: 'A critical incident' is a memorable, significant, or unexpected moment experienced in the classroom. Religious Studies Department associate professor Alison Downie published 'Who Speaks When?' in the Wabash Center Journal of Teaching.ĭownie's article was one of three selected from the journal's call for papers onCritical Incidents in Teaching.

Iup professor alison downie